E/C.12/GC/26
47.
International cooperation and assistance should be focused on supporting national
policies to secure access to land tenure for those whose legitimate user rights have not been
recognized. Policies should avoid leading to land concentration or commodification of land
and should be aimed at improving the access of disadvantaged and marginalized individuals
and groups and increasing their security of tenure. Adequate safeguard policies shall be in
place, and persons and groups affected by measures of international cooperation and
assistance shall have access to independent complaint mechanisms. International cooperation
and assistance can facilitate efforts to ensure that land policies are sustainable and are or will
become an integral part of official land use planning and States’ broader spatial planning.
IV. Specific issues of relevance to the implementation of rights
enshrined in the Covenant in land-related contexts
A.
Internal armed conflicts and post-conflict situations
48.
There are links between internal armed conflicts, land and the enjoyment of rights
enshrined in the Covenant. Sometimes, land conflicts, especially those relating to structural
unequal distribution of land tenure coming, for example, from colonial or apartheid systems,
can be one of the root causes or a trigger of the conflict. In other cases, the conflicts may lead
to forced displacements, land grabbing and land dispossession, especially for populations in
vulnerable situations, such as peasants, Indigenous Peoples, ethnic minorities and women. It
is noteworthy that addressing land disputes and conflicts might be a key to building resilience
and sustaining peace.60 Thus, States should make every effort to prevent land dispossession
during internal armed conflicts. If dispossessions do nevertheless occur, States are obliged to
establish restitution programmes to guarantee to all internally displaced persons the right to
have restored to them any land of which they were arbitrarily or unlawfully deprived.61 States
should also address all those land conflicts that might trigger the re-emergence of an armed
conflict.
49.
Preventive measures to avoid land dispossession during armed conflict should include
at least the following: (a) the establishment of mechanisms for the protection of land tenure
for populations in vulnerable situations; (b) the coordination of humanitarian assistance and
the implementation of international humanitarian law with measures to prevent land
dispossession; (c) the inclusion in information systems of all those estates at risk of
dispossession, not only to prevent dispossession but also to facilitate future land restitution;
and (d) the possibility of freezing the land market in regions in which the risks of internal
displacement and land dispossession are high. All such preventive measures should protect
not only property, but all forms of land tenure, including customary tenure, as those at higher
risk of being dispossessed of their land may not be the formal owners of it.
50.
Land restitution programmes shall include measures to guarantee the right of refugees
and internally displaced persons to a voluntary return to their former lands or places of
habitual residence, in safety and dignity. If restitution is not possible, States should develop
adequate compensation mechanisms.62 States shall establish and support equitable, timely,
independent, transparent and non-discriminatory procedures, institutions and mechanisms to
assess and enforce all land restitution claims. They should cover not only property rights but
all forms of land tenure, especially when they are linked to the enjoyment of rights under the
Covenant. Special attention should be paid to dealing adequately with “secondary
occupants”, who are mostly good faith purchasers, and persons in a vulnerable situation who
occupy land after the legitimate tenants have fled owing to armed conflict. In particular, due
process shall be guaranteed to secondary occupants; if their eviction is necessary, it shall be
implemented with genuine consultation and States shall, if necessary, provide them with
60
61
62
14
See the guidance note of the Secretary-General entitled “The United Nations and Land and Conflict”,
issued in March 2019.
See the principles on housing and property restitution for refugees and displaced persons, endorsed by
the Sub-Commission on the Protection and Promotion of Human Rights (E/CN.4/Sub.2/2005/17).
Ibid.
GE.23-00043