A/HRC/17/26
violations experienced at the intersection of inter- and intra-gender sex discrimination and
violence against women. In 1992 it issued general recommendation No. 19 both to define
gender-based violence and to make it discrimination on the grounds of sex within the
meaning of the Convention. Much of what is set forth in general recommendation No. 19 is
reiterated and refined in the Declaration on the Elimination of Violence against Women.
CEDAW has also addressed the impact of intersecting forms of discrimination against
women and its nexus with gender-based violence. Most recently, in general
recommendation No. 27, which deals with the rights of older women, it recognizes that age
and sex make older women vulnerable to violence, and that age, sex and disability make
older women with disabilities particularly vulnerable.
16.
The above-mentioned developments have been relied on by the Security Council,
the General Assembly and the Human Rights Council to pass resolutions that focus
particular attention on violence against women and girls. For example, both the General
Assembly and the Human Rights Council have identified inter-gender inequality and
discrimination, including gender-based violence, as violating the human rights of women
and girls. Over time, the language of these resolutions has evolved to reflect the heightened
risk of gender-based violence to women suffering intersectional discrimination. As
analyzed within the United Nations human rights framework, “power imbalances and
structural inequality between men and women are among the root causes of violence
against women.”6 This makes violence against women a matter of inter-gender inequality
between women and men. In addition, various resolutions have acknowledged that
discrimination is understood as having multiple forms that combine to heighten the
vulnerability of some women and girls to violence. This reflects an understanding that
discrimination and violence against women is also a matter of intra-gender inequality
among women.
17.
The United Nations discourse regarding violence against women hinges on three
principles: first, violence against women and girls is addressed as a matter of equality and
non-discrimination between women and men; second, multiple and intersecting forms of
discrimination are recognized as increasing the risk that some women will experience
targeted, compounded or structural discrimination; and third, the interdependence of human
rights is reflected in efforts such as those that seek to address the causes of violence against
women related to the civil, cultural, economic, political and social spheres.
18.
Despite such developments, the global discourse on women’s human rights has been
largely restricted to a framework of equality and non-discrimination against women versus
men, i.e. an inter-gender focus, which is based on the male norm around which many major
human rights instruments remain organized. Consequently important challenges remain in
analyzing both non-discrimination and equality as implicating intra-gender differences
among women.
19.
Violence violates the equality and non-discrimination rights of women and girls in
ways that are contingent on women’s material conditions, individual attributes and social
locations. A holistic approach for the elimination of all forms of violence against all women
therefore requires systematic discrimination and marginalization to be addressed.
20.
This report argues that the elimination of violence requires holistic measures that
address both inter-gender and intra-gender inequality and discrimination. The holistic
approach requires rights to be treated as universal, interdependent and indivisible; situating
violence on a continuum that spans interpersonal and structural violence; accounting for
both individual and structural discrimination, including structural and institutional
6
A/HRC/14/L.9/Rev.1
7