A/HRC/56/60
(principle 2 (5)). Specifically, principle 9 (4) provides that: “States shall establish or reinforce
mechanisms for searching for migrants who have gone missing or disappeared within their
territory and on the high seas.”
28.
The Special Rapporteur highlights the commitment made by States engaged in the
Bali Process, including to victim-centred and protection-sensitive strategies and to further
capacity-building of the relevant agencies in search and rescue operations.42
29.
The Special Rapporteur highlights also that effective protection of the right to life
imposes procedural obligations under international human rights law, including obligations
to conduct effective investigations and to ensure accountability for alleged failures of
protection. In Safi v. Greece,43 the European Court of Human Rights found that the steps
taken by the authorities, namely the initiation of criminal proceedings against coastguard
personnel, were insufficient, leading to the finding of a violation of the procedural aspect of
article 2. The Human Rights Committee found a violation of the due diligence obligations
arising under article 6 (1) of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights due to
a failure to respond promptly to a distress call, in the absence of a clear explanation for that
failure.44 The high numbers of deaths and disappearances of migrants and refugees crossing
the Mediterranean Sea has been an ongoing serious concern, raising urgent questions of how
and whether States and other actors, including Frontex, are meeting their obligation to ensure
the protection of the right to life and other fundamental rights. Following the deaths and
disappearances of an estimated 600 persons in the Adriana shipwreck on 14 June 2023, an
investigation was launched by the European Ombudsman into the compliance of Frontex
with its fundamental rights obligations concerning search and rescue in the context of its
maritime surveillance activities, in particular in relation to the Adriana shipwreck. The
Ombudsman concluded, inter alia, that there was a need for greater clarity on roles and
responsibilities and, importantly, on the nature of Frontex’s cooperation with national
authorities and, significantly, that there was a failure to ensure Frontex’s fundamental rights
monitors were sufficiently involved in decision-making on maritime emergencies detected
during Frontex’s surveillance activities.45
V. Identification, assistance and protection: disembarkation and
places of safety
30.
The Special Rapporteur recalls that a place of safety must be interpreted as meaning
a place that can ensure protection of the rights of those disembarked, including, specifically,
the rights of victims and potential victims of trafficking, as well as the prevention of
trafficking in persons, “since the notion of ‘safety’ extends beyond mere protection from
physical danger and must also take into account the fundamental rights dimension of the
proposed place of disembarkation”.46 States are required to ensure respect for human rights
principles, including access to relevant procedures, the prohibition of refoulement and
avoiding serious harm or other risks.47
31.
The positive obligation on States to identify victims of trafficking and persons at risk
of trafficking continues to apply at sea, including during search and rescue operations. It also
applies at disembarkation, imposing obligations on both flag States and port States. The
obligations on States to identify and protect victims of trafficking and persons at risk of
trafficking are positive obligations, not dependent on self-identification, and must take
account of the trauma endured by victims of trafficking, ensuring gender equality, the best
42
43
44
45
46
47
GE.24-06692
Bali Declaration on People Smuggling, Trafficking in Persons, and Related Transnational Crime,
(para. 5), reinforced by the 2023 Adelaide Strategy for Cooperation.
European Court of Human Rights, Safi v. Greece, application No. 5418/15, Judgment, 7 July 2022.
A.S. et al. v. Italy (CCPR/C/130/D/3042/2017). para. 8.5.
See www.ombudsman.europa.eu/en/case/en/63451.
Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly resolution 1821 (2011) on the interception and rescue at
sea of asylum seekers, refugees and irregular migrants, para. 9.5.
UNHCR and others, Joint Statement on Place of Safety, “The concept of place of safety under
international law and the respect of the rights of migrants and refugees rescued at sea by all States”
(May 2022).
9