E/2002/27
E/CN.6/2002/13
report of the Working Group on Communications. This affirmative vote
is due to the following:
1.
The Commission on the Status of Women at its current session
(forty-sixth) was unable to discuss the bulk of the report of the Working
Group and the discussions and negotiations left unfinished before
reaching any consensus on the whole text. Under these circumstances,
any reference by the Commission to the report of the Working Group as
“revised” does not correspond to reality.
2.
No communication from the 1503 procedure should be
considered as a basis for the conclusions supposed to be elaborated by
the Working Group. The current practice of the sharing of information
and communications between the Commission on the Status of Women
and the 1503 procedure is not expected under the present resolutions of
the Economic and Social Council.
3.
According to the provisions of the existing resolutions,
including Council resolution 1983/27, the Working Group is mandated
with the task of “indicating the categories in which communications are
most frequently submitted to the Commission”. Hence there is no legal
basis, in our view, for the Working Group to “express its concern” or to
“note” the violations of human rights based on the communications
forwarded to the Commission on the Status of Women, as the
information received corresponds only to the allegations accompanied
by replies from Governments.
4.
According to Council resolution 1983/27, the Working Group
is mandated with the task of bringing to the attention of the Commission
on the Status of Women those communications “which appear to reveal a
consistent pattern of reliably attested injustice and discriminatory
practices against women” in the form of “categories of
communications”. There are instances in the report of the Working
Group where the conclusion is drawn solely on the basis of just one
communication on an isolated case in one country to which the
concerned Government replied in detail. These kinds of communications
clearly do not constitute any “trend” or “pattern” as stipulated in the
pertinent resolutions, including resolution 1983/27.
5.
The inclusion of the report of the Working Group in the report
of the Commission on the Status of Women to the Economic and Social
Council is neither obligatory nor expected, as the Working Group on
Communications is a subsidiary body of the Commission on the Status
of Women and its reports are addressed to it. It is only the Commission
on the Status of Women that, on the basis of the report of the Working
Group, may decide to make recommendations to its parent body, the
Economic and Social Council. The practice of automatic transmission of
the report of the Working Group to the Council is a wrong innovation.
The delegation of the Islamic Republic of Iran, while extending its
sincere appreciation to the Chairperson, Ambassador Othman Jerandi of
Tunisia, for his able leadership, hard work and the dedication, hopes that
the Commission on the Status of Women would be able, at its forty-
63
Sélectionner le paragraphe cible3
Se connecter à un paragraphe
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Ajouter à la table des matières