A/HRC/56/60
and Turbo, where migrants arrive to travel by sea to Acandí (municipality bordering
Panama), Capurganá (town in Acandí) or directly to Panamanian towns (by using unregulated
sea routes). Those three municipalities are located in an area controlled by an illegal armed
group that controls the mixed movement routes. The Special Rapporteur highlighted the
specific risks for unaccompanied children of trafficking for purposes of exploitation in
criminal activities, sexual exploitation and forced labour. The Special Rapporteur notes that
continued limited pathways for regular migration lead to people taking more dangerous
routes and contribute to the expansion of criminal activities in the region. Changes in
migration and asylum laws and policies in the United States and Mexico have contributed to
fluctuations in the numbers of refugees and migrants taking the sea routes and the onward
dangerous journey through the Darién Gap.23 The Special Rapporteur highlights the urgency
of more support for host communities and a greater role for development actors and
international financial institutions in supporting States in fulfilling protection obligations and
taking action to prevent trafficking in persons.
18.
The Special Rapporteur recalls the resolution on missing migrants and refugees in
Africa and the impact on their families of the African Commission on Human and Peoples’
Rights, in which the Commission “calls on the African Union (AU) to engage the European
Union (EU) within the framework of the AU-EU Partnership for the EU to review its
migration policies and practices to avoid their adverse consequences for African migrants,
including enforced disappearances and death on the Mediterranean”.24 Despite such calls,
disappearances and deaths have continued with impunity.
III. Shared responsibility and questions of jurisdiction
19.
Disputes regarding jurisdiction and a lack of willingness to accept responsibility
contribute to increased risks and failures of prevention and protection at sea. It is critical to
recall that States are responsible for the human rights of all persons within their jurisdiction,
including within their territory and at borders and where they exercise effective power,
control or authority,25 including at sea and on vessels.26 Any State exercising effective control
over a vessel, including through search and rescue operations, is responsible for securing the
human rights of passengers, regardless of their migration status. 27 Those include positive
obligations to identify, assist and protect victims of trafficking, to prevent trafficking in
persons and to ensure accountability for trafficking in persons at sea. In situations in which
States have overlapping or transnational authority at sea, for example on the high seas or in
designated search and rescue areas, all States must fulfil their obligations arising under
international human rights law, including obligations relating to trafficking in persons. 28
States are required to coordinate effectively and to act together to realize those protection
obligations, including to ensure that persons in distress at sea are taken to a place of safety.
However, in practice, States often seek to avoid human rights obligations towards migrants
at sea, including by transferring responsibility to other States and non-State actors. Reports
of migrant vessels in distress in the Mediterranean experiencing difficulties in seeking to
contact the European Border and Coast Guard Agency (Frontex) or the search and rescue
authorities of individual European States are well documented.29
20.
As the Special Rapporteur has previously highlighted in relation to jurisdiction and
the scope of application of obligations relating to trafficking in persons, the positive
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
6
See www.cfr.org/article/crossing-darien-gap-migrants-risk-death-journey-us.
African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights resolution 486.
A/HRC/47/30, para. 38. See also A/HRC/53/28, para. 39.
Committee on Enforced Disappearances, general comment No. 1 (2023), para. 31.
OHCHR, Recommended Principles and Guidelines on Human Rights at International Borders
(Geneva, 2014), principles 8 and 10 and guideline 4. See also United Nations Convention on the Law
of the Sea, art. 98 (1).
A/HRC/47/30, para. 38.
(OHCHR), ���‘Lethal disregard’: search and rescue and the protection of migrants in the central
Mediterranean Sea”, pp. 9–12. See also European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, “June 2023
update – search and rescue operations in the Mediterranean and fundamental rights”, 11 October
2023.
GE.24-06692