A/67/278
46. The background and daily experience of justice sector staff, especially judges,
are often very different from those of persons living in poverty, and this often means
that, without proper training and sensitization, they do not understand and value
their views, choices, behaviours or problems. Persons living in poverty may be
denied access to impartial justice owing to negative stigma and stereotyping from
judges, prosecutors and police.
47. Police forces are the primary and most common interface with the justice
system for persons living in poverty. All too often, however, police actions and
procedures act as a barrier to meaningful access to justice for persons living in
poverty and they are treated as potential criminals, rather than as rights-holders
whose access to justice must be supported and facilitated.
Excessive and arbitrary use of detention and incarceration
48. Across developing and developed countries, incarceration rates are extremely
high for persons living in poverty. Disproportionately high numbers of them are
arrested, detained and imprisoned as a result of law enforcement officials’ frequent
use of poverty, homelessness or disadvantage as an indicator of criminality, and they
encounter considerable obstacles in manoeuvring within or exiting the criminal
justice system.
49. The provision of bail pending trial is often subject to stringent and onerous
conditions. In the vast majority of cases, those requirements are impossible to meet
for the poorest. Therefore, they are more likely to remain in detention pending trial.
This dramatically increases the likelihood that they will ultimately be convicted: not
only does it put them in a vulnerable position, in which they will be more inclined to
accept unfair “plea deals” or to make admissions of guilt in order to secure a swifter
release, it also impedes their ability to liaise with lawyers or obtain character
witnesses, and causes them to lose their employment or social housing, thereby
creating a disincentive for the court to give a suspended or community sentence. 14
50. The economic and social costs of detention and incarceration can be
devastating for persons living in poverty. Detention and incarceration can lead to
loss of income and employment and often temporary or permanent withdrawal of
social benefits. Their families, particularly their children, are also directly affected.
Therefore, criminal justice systems predicated on detention and incarceration, even
for minor non-violent crimes, can themselves represent a significant obstacle to
access to justice for persons living in poverty. Those who are poor and vulnerable
are likely to leave detention disproportionately financially, physically and
personally disadvantaged.
Fees and costs
51. In addition to the costs of legal assistance (see paras. 60-67 below), there are
numerous other costs associated with accessing justice which constitute a major
barrier for the poor, who simply cannot afford those expenditures. Fees are
encountered at every stage of the legal process, along with several indirect costs,
such as for obtaining a legal document, witness costs, commissioning independent
expertise, photocopies and phone calls. The cumulative impact of those costs is a
__________________
14
12
E/CN.4/2006/7, para. 66.
12-45806