E/1999/27
E/CN.6/1999/10
realization and promotion of the human rights of women by putting an end to
discrimination against women in all its forms.
“Regarding article 9, paragraph 2, it is our view that the term ‘inform’ should
be understood as a part of a process of interaction between the States Parties and the
Committee under the inquiry procedure.”
Egypt
“The delegation of Egypt hopes that the adoption of the draft optional protocol
will be an important step in promoting the role of the General Assembly of the United
Nations in enhancing the rule of law in the international community and in strengthening
the rights of women at the threshold of the third millennium. At the same time, Egypt’s
delegation would like on this important occasion to state a number of positions of
principle in the clearest possible terms.
“1. With regard to article 2, the delegation of Egypt stresses that allowing the
submission of communications on behalf of individuals or groups of individuals, as this
article does, must be conditional on their being exceptional and compelling
circumstances in which it is not possible to obtain the consent of the victim to the
submission of such communications. The term ‘groups of individuals’ means requiring
that each individual in the group should be identified separately.
“2. With regard to paragraph 1 of article 8, the delegation of Egypt affirms the
understanding that prevailed in the Working Group, namely that the reference to grave
violations, using the plural form, means the repeated occurrence of such violations.
“3. With reference to article 11, the delegation of Egypt stresses that the duty
of States to ensure that victims or their representatives submitting communications are
not subjected to ill-treatment or intimidation should be within the limits set by national
legislation.
“4. The delegation of Egypt has agreed to the inclusion of article 17 in view
of the protocol’s optional and procedural character, so that it cannot be adduced as a
precedent.
“The delegation of Egypt requests that this statement be included in the official
documents relating to the protocol.”
Germany (on behalf of the European Union and associated countries)
“I have the honour to present this statement in relation to articles 2 and 8 of this
optional protocol on behalf of the delegations of the member States of the European
Union, and on behalf of the delegations of the Central and Eastern European countries
association with the European Union, Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary,
Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia and the associated country
Cyprus, as well as the EFTA country of Switzerland and the EFTA countries members
of the EEA, Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway:
“(a) The delegations referred to above understand the second sentence of article
2 in the light of the practice of existing human rights treaty bodies, as reflected in their
rules of procedure, namely the rules of procedure of the Human Rights Committee, rule
90 (b), the rules of procedure of the Committee on the Elimination of Racial
Discrimination, Rule 91 (b), and the rules of procedure of the Committee against
Torture, Rule 107 (1) (b).
63