A/70/287
achieve positive greenhouse gas mitigation outcomes, climate -mitigation strategies
deprive some of the poorest people on the planet of food security. 56
Bioenergy
63. Biomass energy can be derived from (usually woody) feedstock by means of
processes that run the gamut from simple combustion in a cookstove to biochemical
conversion. Bioenergy may be able to displace fossil fuels. However, a critical
approach is required to combining biomass energy with carbon capture and storage.
This technology involves growing crops that absorb carbon dioxide, burning them to
produce energy and capturing and storing the carbon that results from the
combustion. The main challenges facing the bioenergy industry is avoiding negative
impacts on food production or ecosystem services.
Water diversion for climate-friendly energy production
64. Other examples of reallocation of resources for the benefit of clean energy at
the expense of food security are cleaning coal and constructing dams for the
generation of hydroelectric power. Cleaning coal requires large amounts of water
that could otherwise be used for irrigating arable land, while the construction of
dams for hydroelectricity may affect water supply for agricultural activities
downstream and also flood land that could otherwise be used for food production. 57
Indeed, any mitigation and adaptation policies that affect water resources must
carefully consider competing water uses and the various implications for food
security. Measures that mitigate one type of adverse impact could exacerbate
another. 58
65. Hydropower is presented as a climate-friendly option and a way to increase
water storage infrastructure. However, hydropower can also create conflicts between
water for energy and water for agriculture. 59 For example, indigenous communities
have raised serious objections to the hydroelectric plant in the Alta Verapaz region
in Guatemala owing to violations of environmental and human rights no rms. The
affected people allege that they were never consulted, as required by Guatemalan
law and the rules of the clean development mechanism registration process. 60
Another example is the Barro Blanco Hydroelectric Power Plant Project in Panama.
It has significantly affected the Ngabe Bugle people who live alongside the Tabasara
River. Construction commenced despite evidence that it would impact cultural and
religious sites and access to medicinal plants highly valued by the Ngabe people. 61
__________________
56
57
58
59
60
61
15-10041
T. Searchinger and others, “Do biofuel policies seek to cut emissions by cutting food?”, Science,
vol. 347, No. 6229 (27 March 2015).
Caesens and Padilla Rodríguez, Climate Change and the Right to Food, chap. VI, note 51.
High Level Panel of Experts on Food Security and Nutrition, “Water for f ood security and
nutrition”, chap. II, note 16.
Ibid., para. 1.5.2.
Adriana Herrera Garibay and Fabrice Edouard, Tenure of Indigenous Peoples Territories and
REDD+ as a Forestry Management Incentive: The Case of Mesoamerican Countries (Rome,
FAO, 2012). UN-REDD is the United Nations Collaborative Programme on Reducing Emissions
from Deforestation and Forest Degradation in developing countries.
Carbon Market Watch, “Local realities of CDM projects: a compilation of case studies”,
November 2013. Available from http://carbonmarketwatch.org/wp -content/uploads/2013/11/casestudies-06-mail-2-dec-2013_final_light.pdf. CDM refers to the clean development mechanism.
17/25
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents