A/81/339
to enjoy their human rights without discrimination. 20 Although return is generally
assumed to be the preferred option, local integration may emerge as a preference
where physical destruction intersects with instability and unresolved security
conditions, or where settlement in urban areas has opened access to education,
employment or services. Following disasters, displaced persons typically prefer to
return, though this preference weakens where disasters are recurrent or slow -onset
processes progressively render areas of origin uninhabitable. Planned relocat ions
have also been increasingly implemented across disaster-affected settings as a
measure of last resort. 21 Preferences are shaped by fear, trust in authorities, family
unity and prospects for rebuilding safely and may differ within households – older
persons often wishing to return while younger members prefer the towns where they
have rebuilt livelihoods. Some may choose to return despite the absence of safe and
adequate conditions, with previously experienced violence or trauma feeling more
familiar than the uncertainties of a new environment.
21. The principles of voluntariness, safety and dignity must govern the process. 22
All pathways must be genuinely available, meaning internally displaced persons can
obtain documentation and secure tenure, the right to work, and the full spectrum of
human rights without discrimination where they choose to settle. Reconstruction
plays a critical part in determining whether these pathways become accessible.
22. Voluntary choice implies freedom from coercion and the realistic availability of
each option. It entails access to full, objective, current and accurate information,
including on physical, material and legal safety in areas of origin, integration or
settlement, and on relevant procedures. Intention and perception surveys are among
the most widely used tools for understanding preferences in mass devastation
settings. 23 They cannot, however, substitute for informed consent at the point of
movement. Such surveys may be complemented by go-and-see visits where feasible,
civil documentation support, housing, land and property advice, transport assistance,
family tracing, and reintegration support. 24 Coercion may also be indirect: the closure
of camps or the withdrawal of assistance must not induce movement, and no internally
displaced person may be returned or relocated to any place where their life, safety,
liberty or health would be at risk.
23. Return, local integration or settlement elsewhere must ensure the physical and
material safety of internally displaced persons, who must themselves perceive the
situation as safe. 25 Safety requires not only the absence of immediate threats, but
confidence that the violations and conditions that caused the displacement will not
recur. Reconstruction should incorporate guarantees of non -repetition, including
effective security arrangements, accountable institutions, access to justice, inclusive
governance, transitional justice and measures addressing discrimination.
Reconstruction should also prevent future displacement risks arising from disasters,
climate change and environmental degradation through disaster risk reduction,
resilient infrastructure, risk-sensitive planning, early warning systems, environmental
monitoring and climate adaptation measures. 26 Where areas become uninhabitable,
__________________
20
Inter-Agency Standing Committee, IASC Framework on Durable Solutions for Internally
Displaced Persons (Washington, D.C., Brookings Institution, 2010).
21
See A/HRC/56/47.
22
Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement, principle 28 (E/CN.4/1998/53/Add.2, annex).
23
See Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, Intentions surveys available
at https://www.unhcr.org/what-we-do/build-better-futures/solutions/intentions-surveys.
24
See confidential submission from international NGO/NGO.
25
Joint IDP Profiling Service, Durable Solutions Indicator Library, available at https://informdurablesolutions-idp.org/indicators-2/.
26
Submission from Uzbekistan.
26-12053
7/24
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents