THIRD SECTION CASE OF PAVLOV AND OTHERS v. RUSSIA (Application no. 31612/09) JUDGMENT Art 8 • Positive obligations • Private life • Failure to diligently address longstanding and excessive industrial air pollution and to take adequate protective measures to reduce its effects, so as to prevent applicants’ exposure to related health risks • Art 8 applicable • Excessive pollution levels affecting adversely and to a sufficient extent applicants’ private life • Fair balance between competing interests not struck STRASBOURG 11 October 2022 FINAL 11/01/2023 This judgment has become final under Article 44 § 2 of the Convention. It may be subject to editorial revision.

Select target paragraph3