A/HRC/35/30
violence or violence against women and their gender-neutral approach. This, coupled with
the unavailability of statistical data on violence against women and existing stereotypes,
results in the denial of violence against women and its tolerance or normalization and in
systematic gaps in the protection provided by shelters and protection orders.
Shelters
69.
From its establishment in 1994, the mandate of the Special Rapporteur has included
visiting women’s shelters during country visits, and the information collected during its 23
years of such experience has been used to identify specific gaps and challenges with respect
to shelters. In her first preliminary report, the first mandate holder recognized that the aim
of shelters was to provide battered women with a safe haven and somewhere to go,
providing survival, safety, support, self-esteem and information. In that report the Special
Rapporteur stated that any shelter or refuge system must be viewed only as a component of
a coordinated and multifaceted approach to domestic violence (see E/CN.4/1995/42, para.
139).
70.
The following are among the most common issues raised as serious matters of
concern related to shelters.
Availability, accessibility and funding of shelters and safe alternative housing
71.
The lack or insufficient number of shelters, as well as unavailability of shelters and
alternative safe houses, are issues of concern that are commonly raised. In many instances,
shelters are either not available or the service provided is inadequate to respond to violence
against women. There is also a lack of equitable territorial allocation of shelters, especially
in rural areas.33
72.
Despite some recognition that domestic violence forces women and children to
relocate for safety, too often national Governments do not provide national planning or
funding to establish sufficient numbers, capacity or distribution of shelters around the
country.34 Many shelters receive some funding from States but usually in an unsustainable
manner and only for a specific period of time that does not allow shelters to develop, plan
or provide the required services. Good practice shows that State funding needs to be secure,
sustained and adequate and that shelters should be jointly funded from central government
budgets and from regional or provincial budgets. The State’s obligation to protect women
from violence has to be reflected also in the allocation of adequate financial resources for
shelters and protection measures.
73.
A major challenge in several contexts is ensuring access to safe and affordable
housing options for women and children when they leave a shelter. Many women who have
fled from domestic violence are forced to return to their homes and to face further violence
due to the lack of second-stage shelter facilities. Access to safe and affordable housing for
survivors is insufficient and often inadequate to meet the demand.
Security/confidentiality
74.
The mandate has encountered tension between the notions of security and secrecy of
shelters.35 It is good practice to keep the location of shelters confidential from the general
public and known only to those who can provide women with access to them. States
providing resources and licences to shelters run by civil society organizations could
conduct monitoring and evaluation to determine what is required, while preserving the
confidentiality and security of the shelter. However, in some situations, especially in rural
33
34
35
See, for example, A/HRC/32/42/Add.2, para. 69 (South Africa).
Janet C. Bowstead, “Why women’s domestic violence refuges are not local services”, Critical Social
Policy, vol. 35, No. 3 (August 2015); Deborah Quilgars and Nicholas Pleace, Meeting the Needs of
Households at Risk of Domestic Violence in England: The Role of Accommodation and Housingrelated Support Services (London, Department for Communities and Local Government, Government
of the United Kingdom, 2010). See also A/HRC/11/6/Add.2, para. 84 (Tajikistan) and
A/HRC/23/49/Add.3, para. 101 (h) (Bosnia and Herzegovina).
See, for example, A/HRC/11/6/Add.4, paras. 72 and 83 (h) (Republic of Moldova).
13
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents