A/79/179
opening opportunities for systematic civil society participation, albeit variable across
countries. 13
31. Most voluntary national reviews specifically refer to persons with disabilities,
although to a varying degree. Persons with disabilities are consistently identified
among groups at risk of being left behind, and many reports outline legal and policy
measures to address inequalities and exclusion. Such information is valuable, but
reporting generally appears to be more descriptive rather than assessing the concrete
impact on persons with disabilities. Most disability-specific reporting revolves
around well-known key issues, such as anti-discrimination laws and policies and
related institutional arrangements; social security; employment; education; health;
accessible physical environment, including transport; and disability-disaggregated
data. The thematic focus largely mirrors those Sustainable Development Goals that
specifically target persons with disabilities, while disability-focused reporting on
other Goals is harder to notice.
32. States have increasingly undertaken consultative preparatory processes as part
of the voluntary national reviews, for example, through multi-stakeholder platforms,
consultations led by civil society, calls for inputs, draft reviews, validation of
information and data, and presentation of shadow reports by civil society. In some
countries, different stakeholders therefore have a multitude of opportunities to engage
and contribute.
33. The Special Rapporteur received examples of disability inclusion in the
voluntary national reviews processes highlighting the positive role of civil society
and organizations of persons with disabilities to facilitate outreach, collect
information and suggest solutions. In Kenya, the national umbrella organization of
persons with disabilities is actively engaged in the “SDGs Kenya Forum” – a civil
society platform that co-chairs the technical working committee set up by the
Government to ensure the involvement of all stakeholders in the implementation of the
Sustainable Development Goals. As such, the organization contributed to the civil
society report annexed to the 2024 voluntary national review of Kenya after consulting
organizations of persons with disabilities at the local and regional levels and identifying
progress made, existing gaps and recommendations for addressing them. 14
34. Ideally, the voluntary national review reports themselves should outline the
multi-stakeholder consultative processes undertaken and whether they were inclusive
of persons with disabilities. This seems to be far from the norm as only 9 of the 37
reviews prepared for 2024 specifically identify persons with disabilities as part of the
stakeholders consulted in the review process, most often without providing details
about how such consultations were conducted. 15 Information submitted to the Special
Rapporteur also points to persons with disabilities being excluded from meaningfully
participating in review consultation processes. 16
35. Existing guidelines on voluntary national reviews preparation stress the need for
inclusive and participatory review and follow-up processes on the implementation of
the Sustainable Development Goals in line with the founding principles of the 2030
Agenda. The Department of Economic and Social Affairs issues a regularly updated
handbook for the preparation of voluntary national reviews, including examples and
suggestions on multi-stakeholder engagement and identifying representative voices
from marginalized groups. 17 In his common reporting guidelines for voluntary national
__________________
13
14
15
16
17
24-13229
See www.un.org/en/desa/world-public-sector-report.
See submission from Light for the World. Civil society report can be consulted at
https://sdgkenyaforum.org/vnr-2024.
See https://hlpf.un.org/countries .
See submission from International Disability Alliance.
See https://hlpf.un.org/sites/default/files/2024-01/VNR%20Handbook%202024%20EN.pdf.
9/21
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents